You spent three hours in an offsite meeting crafting your company’s core values. You landed on five compelling words: integrity, innovation, collaboration, excellence, and accountability. You put them on the website, printed posters for the break room, and mentioned them during onboarding. Six months later, nothing changed. Your team still operates exactly as before, and you’re wondering why this exercise felt so empty.
The problem: most companies confuse declaring values with building them into the operating system of their business. Values become meaningful only when they guide daily decisions, shape consequences, and determine who gets promoted or shown the door. Without that integration, they’re just aspirational words on a wall.
Colleen Doyle Bryant, author of Rooted in Decency and creator of character education resources used globally, offers a framework that explains why so many values initiatives fail. In a recent conversation on the Deliberate Leaders podcast, she revealed the critical distinction between different types of values and why sequence matters more than most leaders realize.
Coming up, we’ll explore the three-layer values framework that separates companies with genuine culture from those with window dressing, plus a step-by-step process for identifying and implementing values that drive retention, performance, and competitive advantage.
The Three Layers of Values (And Why Most Companies Skip the Foundation)
Bryant introduces a crucial distinction that most leadership teams miss entirely. There are three types of values operating in every organization, whether you acknowledge them or don’t:
Human values form the foundation. These are universal principles that govern how people form relationships, build trust, and cooperate toward shared goals. They existed before laws, before religions, before modern corporations. Bryant identifies four core human values:
- Honesty: Truthfulness about ourselves and integrity in our dealings with others
- Respect: Treating people the way we want to be treated
- Responsibility: Accountability for our actions and fairness in give-and-take relationships
- Compassion: Supporting each other through difficulties and celebrating successes
Personal values are things that you value in the way that you go about living. Moral values are based on these core human ways of behaving that we all need to be able to work well together. So you can have corporate values and you can have personal values, that’s cool. But they need to be built on top of a foundation of these core human values.
Corporate values sit on top of that foundation. These are the strategic priorities that focus your team’s energy in a particular direction:
- Innovation: Encouraging new ideas and creative problem-solving
- Customer focus: Prioritizing client needs in decision-making
- Speed: Moving quickly to capitalize on opportunities
- Quality: Maintaining high standards in everything you produce
- Sustainability: Making decisions that consider long-term environmental impact
Corporate values answer the question: given that we treat each other with basic decency, what specific behaviors and priorities will drive our competitive advantage?
Personal values represent individual preferences about how someone likes to work and live:
- Autonomy: Preferring independence in decision-making
- Creativity: Valuing innovation and original thinking
- Structure: Appreciating clear processes and predictability
- Adventure: Seeking novelty and new experiences
- Stability: Prioritizing consistency and security
Personal values describe style and preference.
The mistake most companies make: they jump straight to corporate values without ensuring the foundation of human values exists first. They declare “we value transparency and innovation” while employees experience managers who lie about project timelines and punish people for speaking up with new ideas. The gap between stated values and lived experience creates cynicism that’s nearly impossible to reverse.
Bryant explains why this foundation matters so urgently:
When you look at why people are leaving companies, the first six months of the great attrition, the leading cause of people leaving companies is a toxic workplace. It was 10 times more powerful in predicting people leaving than compensation was. And when you look at what are the ways people define a toxic workplace, they are respect, honesty, responsibility and fairness.
How to Know If Your Foundation Is Broken
Before you invest energy defining corporate values, assess whether your human values foundation needs repair. Three diagnostic questions reveal the truth:
Can people speak honestly without fear of retaliation? Watch what happens when someone delivers bad news to leadership:
- Healthy response: They get thanked for raising the issue and leadership works to address it
- Toxic response: They face subtle punishment through exclusion, difficult assignments, or being labeled “negative”
If people carefully manage what they say around executives, you have an honesty problem.
Do employees feel respected regardless of their role or tenure? Notice how senior leaders interact with junior employees:
- Respectful environment: Executives value input from all levels and honor commitments equally
- Disrespectful environment: Leaders routinely cancel meetings with direct reports but never with clients, or managers make jokes at employees’ expense
If executives treat some people’s time and contributions as more valuable than others based on hierarchy rather than circumstance, you have a respect problem.
Are people held accountable consistently? Examine what happens when someone misses a deadline, delivers poor work, or treats colleagues badly:
- Consistent accountability: Consequences apply equally regardless of who violated standards
- Inconsistent accountability: High performers and favorites get exceptions while others face punishment for the same behavior
If accountability feels arbitrary or political, you have a responsibility problem.
These foundation cracks will sabotage any corporate values you try to build on top. A company that claims to value “bold innovation” but punishes people for honest mistakes will never see breakthrough ideas. A company that espouses “teamwork and collaboration” while tolerating managers who berate their staff will struggle with silos and turf wars.
Finding Your Strategic Corporate Values
Once your foundation is solid (or you’ve committed to repairing it), you can identify the corporate values that will drive your competitive positioning. This process requires more thought than most leadership teams give it.
Start with your strategic position, then work backward. What capabilities must your organization excel at to win in your market? If you compete on speed to market, you might value decisiveness and agility. If you compete on quality and reliability, you might value precision and thoroughness. If you compete on customer intimacy, you might value empathy and responsiveness.
Your values should create natural tradeoffs that guide difficult decisions. When two good options compete for resources, your values tell you which one aligns better with your strategy.
Limit yourself to three to five corporate values. More than five values become impossible to remember and apply consistently. Fewer than three might leave important gaps. Each value you choose should be:
- Distinct from the others (avoid overlap like “integrity” and “honesty”)
- Specific enough to guide behavior (avoid generic terms like “excellence”)
- Connected to your competitive advantage
- Defensible under pressure (you’ll uphold this even when costly)
Test your draft values against real decisions. Think about the hardest call you made in the past year. Would your proposed values have provided clear guidance? If the values would have pointed you toward a choice you ultimately rejected, they’re the wrong values. Your actual priorities reveal your true values, even when they conflict with your aspirational ones.
Bryant emphasizes that this clarity serves everyone:
A corporation is going to add a layer of values that helps focus people in a direction. So they’re going to say, let’s say, for instance, in our corporation, we value innovation and customer-centric activities. So when you are thinking about your priorities, when you’re planning your work, focus in that direction, and it gets people marching in one way and having a frame of reference when they’re thinking about what to do.
Making Values Operational Through Decisions
Values become real through the decisions they influence and the behaviors they reward or punish. Five integration points transform words into culture:
Hiring and Interviewing
Add values-based questions to every interview. Go beyond asking candidates if they align with your values (everyone says yes) and probe for evidence of past behavior.
For a value of “ownership and accountability,” ask: “Tell me about a project that failed or missed its target. What was your role in that outcome? What would you do differently?” Listen for whether they own their contribution or blame circumstances and other people.
For a value of “customer obsession,” ask: “Describe a time you had to choose between what was easier for your team and what was better for the customer. What did you do?” Look for examples where they chose the harder path that served the customer.
Create a simple scoring rubric tied to each value. Rate candidates on a 1-5 scale for values alignment, weighted equally with skills and experience. A candidate who scores high on skills but low on values is a bad hire, period.
Onboarding and Orientation
Introduce values on day one with specific behavioral examples of what each value looks like in your organization. Generic definitions mean nothing without context.
If you value “transparency,” explain what that means practically. Does it mean sharing financial results with the entire team? Does it mean managers explaining the reasoning behind decisions? Does it mean admitting mistakes publicly? Show new hires exactly how this value manifests in your company.
Share stories of employees who exemplified each value, including situations where living the value required sacrifice or difficult choices. Stories stick in ways that definitions do not.
Performance Management
Evaluate employees on both results and values alignment. A common framework: 50% of the performance rating comes from what they achieved, 50% from how they achieved it.
An employee who hits their numbers but violates values (treats colleagues disrespectfully, takes shortcuts on quality, hoards information) should receive a low overall rating. An employee who fully embodies values but falls slightly short on metrics should receive coaching on skills while being recognized for their cultural contribution.
This forces honest conversations. You cannot promote someone who gets results through toxic behavior while claiming you value respect and collaboration. Your promotion decisions signal your true values more loudly than any poster or speech.
Recognition and Rewards
Publicly acknowledge employees who demonstrate your values, especially when doing so came at a personal cost. Share the specific situation and why it matters.
Example: “I want to recognize Sarah for living our value of customer focus. She discovered a defect in a product that had already shipped and immediately notified the customer, even though it meant admitting our mistake and delaying payment. That’s integrity in action.”
Make values alignment a formal criterion for bonuses, spot awards, and peer recognition programs. What gets rewarded gets repeated.
Tough Decisions and Tradeoffs
The ultimate test of values: do they guide you when the cost is high? Bryant explains the concept of public justification:
In our personal lives, we can think whatever we want around our kitchen table. But when we’re in a public space where we’re working with other people and we need to cooperate and compromise, then our justifications need to come from shared values. By relating it to those things that we have agreed upon by the nature of being in this relationship in the corporation, then you have a reasonable argument.
When you need to make a difficult decision that will affect multiple stakeholders, explain your reasoning through the lens of your values. “This choice aligns with our value of X, even though it means accepting Y consequence.” This transparency builds trust even when people disagree with the outcome.
The Family Business Values Trap
Bryant offers particular insight for family businesses, where the lines between personal relationships and professional accountability often blur:
Family relationships, true family relationships, have different standards. They have different expectations, different boundaries, different give and take than that next bubble out, which is coworkers. It’s really wise to make sure that the way you’re handling those relationships are different, in that even your family member at work is a different relationship than your family member at home.
If you run a family business, separate family values from workplace values explicitly. The loyalty, unconditional support, and extensive give-and-take appropriate for family relationships create problems when applied to the broader team. Non-family employees will feel excluded, held to different standards, or expected to give more than the implicit employment contract requires.
Make clear that everyone, including family members, operates under the same workplace values while at work. The fact that your son or daughter works for the company doesn’t exempt them from accountability standards. In fact, hold family members to a higher standard to prove that values apply universally.
When Personal Values Conflict With Company Values
Employees bring their personal values to work. Sometimes those personal values align beautifully with your corporate values. Sometimes they conflict. Bryant offers a clear framework for handling this tension.
Personal values that relate to work style (preferring structure versus flexibility, favoring collaboration versus independent work, seeking novelty versus consistency) should be accommodated where possible. These are preferences about how someone operates most effectively.
Personal values that conflict with the foundational human values or your core corporate values create an incompatibility that cannot be resolved. Bryant explains:
By being part of humanity, you are agreeing to these core human values that say we should act with integrity and decency toward each other. Go home to your kitchen table and do what you want. But in public, in those situations, if you disagree and your personal value is in conflict with those shared values, you need to be able to explain in terms of what we all agree on.
An employee who personally values radical honesty (saying exactly what they think without filtering) must still communicate respectfully at work. An employee who personally values individual achievement above all else must still collaborate effectively on team projects. Personal values don’t override professional obligations.
When the conflict runs deeper (an employee’s core beliefs fundamentally oppose company values), the person should find a company whose values align better with their worldview. Trying to force alignment in these cases creates misery for everyone involved.
For a deeper exploration of how moral values, personal values, and corporate values interact in practice, listen to this conversation with Colleen Doyle Bryant on the Culture of Leadership podcast:
Keeping Values Alive as You Scale
Values drift as companies grow. What felt natural when you had 10 people requires intentional systems at 50 people and formal programs at 200 people. Three practices prevent drift:
Conduct quarterly values audits. Survey employees anonymously about whether they see values being lived:
- Ask for specific examples of values being upheld
- Request instances where values were violated
- Track trends showing where culture is strong and where it’s eroding
- Share results transparently and commit to addressing gaps
Make values violations grounds for separation. The fastest way to kill culture is tolerating people who consistently violate values:
- Address violations immediately and publicly (without naming individuals)
- Communicate clearly that the behavior violated company values
- Confirm the person responsible is no longer with the company
- Reinforce that values matter more than short-term performance
Example: “We recently became aware of a manager who was taking credit for their team’s work. That violates our value of integrity and respect. We’ve addressed the situation, and that person is no longer with the company.”
Revisit values during strategy reviews. As your market position evolves, your corporate values may need adjustment. The values that served you as a scrappy startup might differ from what you need as an established market leader. Check annually whether your values still drive your competitive advantage.
Bryant notes that values must remain connected to behavior:
If you’re going to say these things matter, and this is what we believe and how it should work, well, then you have to enforce it. Then accountability and that enforcement aspect of responsibility has to be there.
The Competitive Advantage of Genuine Values
Companies with authentic, well-implemented values outperform their peers across multiple dimensions. Research from MIT Sloan found that organizations with healthy cultures experience lower-than-average turnover even during mass resignation periods. Gallup data shows companies with highly engaged workforces (engagement flows from values alignment) are 21% more profitable.
The mechanism is straightforward. When people understand what matters, trust that leadership will uphold those principles, and see their colleagues rewarded for living the values, they make better decisions faster. They don’t need to check with six people before acting. They self-organize around the right priorities. They stay longer, refer better candidates, and go the extra mile when it matters.
Your values become your competitive moat. Competitors can copy your products, your pricing, your marketing. They cannot easily replicate a culture built on genuine values lived consistently over years.
The work begins with honesty about where you stand today. Do your employees experience the four foundational human values in their daily work? Can you articulate three to five corporate values that truly guide your hardest decisions? Are you willing to enforce those values even when doing so costs you a high performer or a profitable client?
If you’re ready to move beyond values as decoration and build them into your operating system, schedule a complimentary strategy session with one of our business coaches. We’ll help you assess your current state, define values that drive performance, and create the systems that make values stick as you scale.
Not sure if you're the bottleneck? Find out in 2 minutes →







