Why Most Growth Strategies Fail

Allison Dunn

Table of Contents

The advertising industry just learned a hard lesson about measuring what matters. Business owners would do well to pay attention.

Three years ago, the Chief Marketing Officer of a Fortune 500 company sat across from her CFO trying to explain why the advertising budget needed to increase by 40%. She had dashboards showing millions of impressions, thousands of clicks, and detailed attribution models mapping every customer touchpoint. The CFO asked one question: “If we cut this spend in half tomorrow, what happens to revenue?” She had no answer.

That conversation has been happening in boardrooms everywhere for the past few years. The advertising industry spent two decades building increasingly sophisticated systems to track and target customers, only to discover those systems measured everything except the thing that mattered. When privacy changes and browser updates dismantled their tracking infrastructure, most marketing teams realized they had been flying blind all along.

The parallels to how business owners operate are striking. We build companies on activity and effort, measuring inputs while hoping outputs follow. We convince ourselves that working harder will eventually break through to the next level. Coming up: why the shift happening in advertising right now offers a framework for how to think about scaling your business, and what you can learn from an industry forced to rebuild its measurement systems from scratch.

What Broke in Digital Advertising

For years, digital marketing operated on proxy metrics. Teams optimized for clicks, impressions, engagement rates, and cost per acquisition. Attribution models claimed to assign credit for every conversion across dozens of touchpoints. U.S. internet ad revenue hit $259 billion in 2024, with roughly 91% of digital display ads purchased through programmatic systems that promised precision targeting and measurement.

Then Apple introduced App Tracking Transparency. Google announced plans to deprecate third-party cookies. European privacy regulations tightened. The infrastructure supporting all that tracking started crumbling. Attribution models that claimed to know exactly which ad drove which sale suddenly showed massive gaps. Customer acquisition costs spiked across industries.

The crisis forced a fundamental question: had anyone ever actually proven that all this targeting and tracking created incremental value? The answer, for most companies, was no. They had measured activity, assumed causation, and built entire departments around optimizing metrics that turned out to be largely decorative.

The Shift to Incrementality

The marketing teams that survived this transition made a conceptual shift. They stopped asking “how many people saw our ad” and started asking “how many additional sales happened because we ran this campaign.” The difference seems subtle. The implications are profound.

Incrementality means measuring lift above a baseline. If you spend $100,000 on advertising and revenue increases by $150,000, you need to know how much of that increase would have happened anyway. Maybe you have strong seasonality. Maybe your product was already gaining momentum. Maybe your sales team closed some big deals that had nothing to do with the ads.

The only way to know is to run controlled experiments. Hold back a portion of your audience and measure the difference between those who see your intervention and those who do not. Marketing Mix Modeling came back into favor. Holdout tests became standard practice. Clean rooms allowed measurement without exposing raw customer data.

This approach required abandoning comfortable assumptions. Many tactics that seemed valuable in the old measurement framework produced zero incremental lift when properly tested. Budget got reallocated fast. Entire channels got cut. The organizations that adapted quickly gained significant competitive advantages while others kept optimizing vanity metrics.

How This Applies to Your Business

Most business owners operate the same way those marketing teams did before the reckoning. We track activity as a proxy for value creation. We attend more meetings, send more emails, work longer hours, and assume those inputs translate to better outcomes. We rarely stop to measure whether any specific thing we do creates incremental value above what would have happened otherwise.

Consider a typical week. You probably have recurring meetings that consume hours of calendar time. You review reports and dashboards. You put out fires. You coach team members. You work on strategic initiatives. All of this feels necessary and productive. The question is whether removing any of these activities would actually decrease business performance.

Like those CMOs with their attribution models, we confuse measurement with understanding. Tracking time spent on activities tells you nothing about whether those activities create value. You need a different framework.

Building Your Measurement System

The advertising industry’s solution was to build measurement systems focused on incremental outcomes. Business owners need the same thing. Here’s how to think about constructing one.

Define Your Outcome Metrics

Start with what actually matters. Revenue, profit margin, customer retention, cycle time for key processes, or capacity utilization. Pick three to five metrics that directly indicate whether your business is creating value. These become your baseline.

Many businesses track dozens of KPIs and call this data-driven management. The proliferation of metrics becomes noise that obscures understanding. You need a small set of numbers that, if they move in the right direction, mean the business is winning. Everything else is supporting detail.

This takes discipline. Executives love comprehensive dashboards because they create the appearance of control. A handful of outcome metrics feels uncomfortably sparse. The sparseness is the point. When you have five numbers to watch, you can actually watch them. When you have fifty, you watch none of them closely.

Create Baselines Through Testing

Once you know what outcomes matter, you need baseline performance. This means establishing what happens when you do nothing different. Track your key metrics over enough time to understand normal variation. Maybe revenue fluctuates 10-15% month to month due to seasonality or deal timing. Maybe profit margins compress predictably during certain quarters.

Understanding the baseline lets you distinguish signal from noise when you make changes. If you implement a new sales process and revenue increases 12% the next month, you need to know whether that sits within normal variation or represents genuine improvement. The baseline gives you this context.

This takes patience. Many business owners want to change everything at once and measure improvement immediately. The advertising teams that succeeded in their transition spent months building clean baseline data before testing interventions. You need the same foundation.

Test Changes Systematically

With baselines established, you can test changes and measure incremental impact. This means changing one thing at a time and giving it enough time to show effects. It means resisting the urge to implement five initiatives simultaneously and hoping something works.

Consider a concrete example. You believe your weekly operations meeting consumes time without creating value. The incrementality question is: if you eliminate this meeting, do your outcome metrics stay flat, improve, or decline?

To test this properly, you would:

  1. Document your baseline performance on the metrics you care about over the previous 8-12 weeks.
  2. Cancel the meeting for a defined trial period (say, 6-8 weeks).
  3. Track whether coordination problems emerge through other channels. Do people start scheduling more ad-hoc meetings? Do issues that used to surface in the operations meeting now get escalated directly to you?
  4. Measure the same outcome metrics during the trial period and compare to your baseline.
  5. Make a decision based on evidence. If performance stayed flat or improved and no critical communication gaps opened, eliminate the meeting permanently. If metrics declined or coordination problems multiplied, bring the meeting back with modifications.

This systematic approach to testing is how you build a business based on evidence. Most business owners skip this discipline. They change things based on intuition, hope the results improve, and move on to the next initiative before measuring whether the previous one worked.

What You Will Discover

When advertising teams started measuring incrementality rigorously, they discovered that many tactics producing impressive-looking metrics created zero lift in outcomes. Entire channels got eliminated. Budgets shifted dramatically. The same thing will happen in your business.

You will likely find that a significant portion of how you spend time produces no measurable value. Meetings that feel important do nothing. Reports nobody reads. Processes maintained because they have always existed. Initiatives that sounded strategic when launched but created no momentum.

This can feel uncomfortable. When you measure rigorously, you have to confront the gap between the story you tell yourself about how the business works and what the evidence shows. Many executives prefer the comfortable story to the uncomfortable evidence.

The discomfort is temporary. Once you eliminate activities that create no value, you free up capacity to focus on what actually drives outcomes. The businesses that went through this process in advertising moved faster, allocated resources better, and gained advantages over competitors still optimizing vanity metrics. The same opportunity exists for you.

Why This Matters Now

The economic environment in 2026 rewards efficiency and punishes waste. Capital costs more. Customers buy more carefully. Talent expects clear direction. The margin for sloppy operations has narrowed considerably.

Businesses built on the assumption that effort translates to value are struggling. The ones that measure incrementality and kill what does not work are pulling ahead. This gap will widen.

Think about what the advertising industry went through as a preview of broader trends. Technology changes forced measurement systems to evolve. Privacy regulations removed convenient shortcuts. The teams that adapted quickly built sustainable advantages. The ones that clung to old frameworks kept spending money on tactics that delivered no incremental value.

Your industry may face similar disruption. AI tools are changing how work gets done. Economic pressures are forcing efficiency improvements. Competitive dynamics are accelerating. The question is whether you will be among the first to build measurement systems that distinguish value from activity, or whether you will keep optimizing effort while competitors measure outcomes.

Where to Begin

The process outlined here takes time to implement properly. You need to identify outcome metrics, establish baselines, design tests, collect data, and make decisions based on evidence. This can feel overwhelming when you are already stretched managing current operations.

Start small. Pick one area where you suspect effort and value have become disconnected. Maybe a recurring meeting. Maybe a report you produce. Maybe a process maintained for historical reasons. Set up a proper test. Measure the baseline. Make the change. Track what happens. Make a decision based on what the data shows.

The first test is the hardest. You are establishing new muscles around disciplined measurement. Once you see how much clarity a single well-designed test provides, the value becomes obvious. The second test comes easier. The third easier still. Over time, this way of thinking becomes how you operate.

The businesses that do this build competitive advantages that compound over time. They operate with less waste. They make faster decisions. They allocate resources to activities that create value and eliminate ones that do not. They grow sustainably while competitors grind harder and wonder why results plateau.

The Larger Pattern

The advertising industry’s forced evolution from activity-based to outcome-based measurement represents a broader pattern. When easy growth ends, systems that looked sophisticated reveal themselves as decorative. Measurement frameworks built on proxies and assumptions break down under scrutiny. The organizations that survive these transitions are the ones willing to rebuild their understanding from first principles.

Most business owners will resist this work. It requires confronting uncomfortable truths about how much current activity creates value. It demands discipline around testing and measurement that feels slow compared to just trying things and hoping they work. It means accepting that many tactics that seemed important produce no incremental benefit.

The alternative is continuing to optimize effort while hoping it translates to outcomes. That approach worked fine when growth came easily and waste went unnoticed. Those conditions no longer apply for most businesses. The question is not whether to build better measurement systems. The question is whether you will do it before your competition does.

If you want help designing measurement systems and running proper tests to understand what creates value in your business, we should talk. Our coaches work with business owners building evidence-based operations that scale without depending on heroic effort. Schedule a complimentary strategy session to explore whether this approach fits your situation.

Not sure if you're the bottleneck? Find out in 2 minutes →

Share This

How long does it take to see results from this approach?

The first test takes 8-12 weeks for baseline plus 6-8 weeks for testing. You will have clear evidence about one activity within three to four months. Results compound as you test more.

Smaller businesses can still test systematically. Use shorter baseline periods (4-6 weeks) and focus on high-impact activities first. Even directional evidence from proper tests beats guesswork.

Pick metrics where improvement means the business wins: revenue, profit margin, customer retention, or cycle time. Avoid metrics that measure activity. If the metric could look good while business performance declines, choose differently.

Proper tests are reversible. Track what happens during the test period. If critical gaps emerge or metrics decline significantly, restore the activity. Testing means learning, sometimes by discovering that something matters more than you thought.

Testing multiple changes simultaneously makes results uninterpretable. You cannot know which change caused which effect. Discipline around single-variable testing provides clean evidence that compounds into competitive advantage over time.

Picture of Allison Dunn
Allison Dunn

Allison Dunn spent 25 years as an owner and executive of several businesses, including an engineering firm, manufacturing company, and architectural firm. In 2013, Allison founded Idaho’s top-ranked business coaching company, Deliberate Directions.

Table of Contents

CEO Bundle

Think strategically. Lead intentionally.

Get 10 free worksheets to help you lead like a high-performing CEO. You’ll also get bonus tips and coaching delivered to your inbox.

Get Bigger Wins

Talk about your biggest challenge or your greatest opportunity with coach Allison Dunn.

Achieve More with Less

In one session, discover how the top 1% of leaders create massive impact without burning out. Work smarter, scale faster, and stay ahead of your competition.

Reach Higher

Learn practical strategies the top 1% use to grow profits, build winning teams, and dominate markets.

Stop Guessing, Start Growing

In one session, gain clarity, uncover hidden opportunities, and leave with an actionable plan.

Coach Allison Dunn has helped businesses like yours achieve remarkable growth.

Your Most Important Meeting This Year

Speak with one of the top 1% of business coaches. In one FREE session, you’ll get:

✓ A clear path forward
✓ Strategies tailored to you
✓ The confidence to act